CHALLENGE: 2009 Social Media Case Studies

in Case study, Social Media

dolphin and cow

If you attended any social media webinar, seminar, conference, panel or similar session in the last 12 months, the case studies referenced by the speakers to showcase the value of social media likely included Dell, Blend-Tec, Starbucks and/or Comcast.

And you probably heard them referenced multiple times by multiple people. The problem was that the social media professionals (call them consultants, gurus, experts, whatever) would take the microphone and share the same four or five stories to illustrate successful examples of  corporate social media work. It was the same redundant thing every time.

I’m just as guilty as everyone else. Those case studies were standards in my deck over the last year and honestly, they were fantastic for introducing the possibilities of social media to an audience largely unfamiliar with the platforms and skeptical of their relevance. I might still use them from time to time with people new to the subject. But really, it’s time to move on.

If you’re still unfamiliar with these case studies, there is ample reference material online that I’ll link to here:

GOOD NEWS

It worked! The hundreds of hours spent evangelizing the benefits of social media combined with the crappiness of the current economy transformed words to action. Many brands have launched blogs, signed up for Twitter and established Facebook Fan pages. Often these case studies helped them to do it.

BAD NEWS

Many still don’t get it. It’s not enough to just set up a social media account and check it off the list. There’s still a lack of strategy behind many of these engagements, and part of the blame falls on how it’s presented (while the other part is management bureaucracy, budgets and a whole lot of other factors beyond our control). As trusted advisors, it’s important we illustrate the benefits of a solid social media strategy by using examples from a diverse set of industries.

OUR JOB

If you are someone who is fortunate enough to have a speaking gig or two lined up in 2009 , I hope you’ll come armed with some new case studies. It would be very impressive if they were case studies from projects you actually worked on. At the very least, conduct a bit of original research so that your version of the case study has a nugget or two that we haven’t heard a thousand times before. We don’t want to hear only about companies that are doing a great job, but those that struggled out of the gate as well. We don’t want only big companies, but also small businesses and players in the B2B space.

You can start by checking out this wiki by Peter Kim that is updated with the latest and greatest examples of corporate social media.

Of course, I’m going to do the same. The gauntlet has been thrown. Bring it.

Photo credit: Tidewater_Muse

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]
  • Great work Aaron. I found your work meaningful, well written and easy to understand, excellent work here. However, for those of you that want to by-pass the intelectual experience and begin to immediately get into the profit. Affiliate marketing and social networking is the way to go: http://www.princeprofit.net

    thank-you, Lorri for making the introduction.
  • I share real stories of real people. As a community manager with 11,000 members the stories are heartfelt, touching and illustrate the true power of online communities. Yes, I know the corporate big wigs want to hear of the successes of other corporate big wigs, but what about the woman who was out of work for months and shared her angst and fears from the day she was fired to the day she finally found a new job? I witnessed this. After looking for three solid months she finally got fed up and posted her resume as a blog post in the community. Well, she received a slew of comments giving her tips on ways to improve her resume and she did. She got the first job she applied for after using the revamped resume that was overhauled for free, by caring community members who wanted to see her succeed. A different kind of success, but success no less.
  • @ Adam - That's great! I don't think the company matters so much as knowing the industry, region, etc. It just shows that there are lots of different types of companies trying these new tools.

    @ Will - Thanks for commenting. Please do share the results when you can.

    @ Terra - I agree. It's more persuasive when you can show that it's not just advantageous for "the big guys."
  • During most of my speaking engagements, I generally prefer using my own case studies that detail results of past clients or colleagues, simply because many people think that larger companies (like Dell and Starbucks) have an unfair advantage of already being well-known to general audiences, and they recieve a lot of attention to their social media efforts due to sheer word-of-mouth and a "hey look at what they're doing" mentality.

    Some of my clients allow me to use their name, and some allow me to talk about what industry they're in, but not their name. Either way, it works out well.
  • Aaron, great timing. For me, anyway. I am wrapping up the first of two phases of a before-and-after case study for a mid-size non-profit. I will let you know when the second phase is finished, and share with you whatever results my client allows me to release. Looking forward to seeing the results of this post!
  • I speak about once a week, and I use my own case studies. Unfortunately, I generally can't reveal the names of the clients, but they're all leading lifestyle brands, and I can generally tell you what market they're in (i.e. 3rd largest city in America, well-known tissue brand, etc.).

    -Metz
  • James
    Dell's use of twitter campign is a very much used case study in all the Conferences!
    James
    Social Media Link Building Services
blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post: UPCOMING EVENT: Social Media Breakfast NYC This Thursday

Next post: Blog Analysis: Safeway